One of the things I have become over the last few years is a student of the public management of a private emotion called grief.
I was terrible at it in the beginning. Oh, good lord, the things I wrote, the things I said ten years ago. Not that I regret having felt any of it but I cannot imagine putting any of that on the Web for the world to misinterpret and crucify me for now. I got better at it, if you can call it that, mainly because, well, enough practice, and one gets better at these things. I had a lot of practice because I have lost a lot of people to untimely death in the last ten years.
Death is, by nature, an everyday occurrence but these seemed like freak tragedies to me; I guess that's because you never think it can happen to someone that you love. The first one was a friend to murder, in 2001. The second was a friend, and soon-to-be roommate (my last call to her was about the apartment I had booked us to look at) who was in a horrific car accident in 2004. The third was like an uncle to me, a friend of my family for forty years, whose daughters were my age and I'd grown up with, and would have been legally responsible for my sister and I had my parents met an untimely end, succumbed very suddenly to a brain tumor in early 2005. The fourth was the death of a child; the daughter of a close friend, in birth, one month later that same year (2005...kind of sucked). The fifth was someone I loved very much, someone I was always convinced was a case of right person, wrong timing, and that someday, I'd find a way to tell him how I felt about him and we'd find a way to be together; he was taken in a horrific motorcycle accident in 2006. The sixth cause hasn't quite yet been determined; I have heard that so far, it looks like an intentional suicide, which absolutely kills me. I found out this past Friday morning.
These friends all came in and out of my life at different phases and times, and were of varying closeness to me at varying points. I have photographs of myself with each. The earliest was Bill, when I was three; I'm on a rocking horse at his house and he's behind me and their old, crotchety Daschshund, Willy, is milling around in the background. I haven't seen the photo itself in years but it's burned into my brain like any other memory; a hard-fired moment in time: There's Bill, and Siobhan, out in the backyard of Bill's old house in Hope Ranch. I can feel she sun on the top of my head and I can hear him telling me to smile for the camera.
There's a photograph of Britt that I love; it's from 1996, the year we met, and he's standing in my living room in my old fleaflop on Cahuenga Boulevard, and he's holding a gin gimlet and saying something, so he wasn't smiling; he's midsentence, but the photgraph makes him look somehow regal in its candidness. His hair is undone but he's got a bit of eyeliner on and he's wearing a Death t-shirt (for the uninitiated, when I say Death I mean the Neil Gaiman character). I think he's wearing his old leather jacket; I'd had one just like it, with these weird circular pads on the lumbar strip, that I wore throughout high school, only to lose track of it one night at Kontrol Faktory in 1994.
There are other photographs. None of them were posted to Facebook. They're posted to my brain, though, and there they live. But as the space, as it were, has evolved, the collective reaction to the death of the people we love, who have also interacted alongside us online, has changed, as has my own. We interpret the absence, and manifest our grief, much differently now.
When news of C's death started to percolate through the diaspora of those who knew her during her tragic and short life over the weekend, my heart sank. Would this become a free-for-all? I checked her profile, hoping that everyone was being nice, at least. Everyone has friends, but everyone has enemies, too, and when those we love pass on, it brings out the best in some, and the worst in others. Predictably, a particularly nasty, small-minded ex-boyfriend had to weigh in on it. I didn't have access to the post but I heard about it, on Facebook, of course. I shut my eyes and tried to pretend I hadn't read it but I wanted to hit something. She's gone, you jackass, can't you focus on something besides you for once? Focus on the love you once had, who you used to be? Who she was?
(And admittedly, did any of us really know who she was? We all had lost her, over the recent years, as she pulled away, the demons that plagued her forcing her inward, withdrawing from all of us and into a different life but we did love her. We just hoped that she was off straightening her life out and that eventually, she would come back to us.)
But this is Facebook, this is the Web, and even if I see him in a crowded nightclub, I'll never look at or speak to that guy again, I'm so embarrassed and angry. What we do online has an impact offline. I see the words and I can choose how to react; and in this situation, in this place, my reaction is one of deletion. Get out of my brainspace.
And there C's profile sits. Forever thirty-five. Forever frozen there, only the next time that something steamrolls over the Last Great Social Network, she won't make the jump with us. Her mother has posted comments twice in the last two days, desperate pleas of a woman in a grip of pain I can scarcely contemplate. I want to reach out and hug her, tell her it's going to be okay, but I can't do that. All she has are profile pictures and a random assortment of status updates from the last few years. And a lot of questions: what happened? why? and who are all these people? and I think my mother would probably think the exact same thing, if she were in her place.
What happens to a Facebook user when they die? It's not a technical question. It's an emotional question. Certainly not one we asked when Wendy died in 2000; we didn't have social networks, at least, not in their present form, then. Hyatt's Livejournal still exists, though she was removed from life support on my 30th birthday: July 31, 2004. So does Britt's (he had one, too). There they sit; their accounts, untended. As the Web has moved on, there they remain.
I know that so many people know that she's gone, and yet, there's been near-total silence about the whole thing. I don't get it. In an era of the overshare, we've all gone mute. It's scary, and strange. I think most of us are afraid of saying the wrong thing, being tacky, or inappropriate, so we're doing nothing. Saying nothing. Wondering if we should report it, or something. Hoping someone, anyone, posts the details of a funeral date and time and place so we can show up in person for our friend instead of leaving comments she'll never see on a Facebook profile that apparently doesn't accurately represent her or what was honestly going on in her life anyway. Time magazine say they have answers. I disagree.
In her photographs, she looks so beautiful; that never changed. But she also looks happy, and I can see the supportive, cheerful comments to her friends and the upbeat tone to her interactions and that's where the deceptive nature of Facebook kicks in. Everyone looks happy, and relaxed, and normal, and we know now that that could not have been further from the truth; she wasn't happy. In fact, we should probably just assume that nobody is.